CTR on Google AI Overviews vs Regular SERPs: What the Data Shows
When Google shows an AI Overview, fewer people click the blue links below it. That is not a hunch anymore. Several large studies now measure the same gap: results pages with AI Overviews get fewer organic clicks than regular SERPs. This post puts those numbers side by side and explains what they mean for brands.
The 60-second version
- Ahrefs’ updated study finds position-one organic CTR about 58% lower when an AI Overview is present (December 2025 data), up from a 34.5% gap in their earlier study.
- Pew Research found users clicked a traditional result on 8% of visits with an AI summary vs 15% without one. Clicks on links inside the AI summary itself were about 1%.
- Seer Interactive saw organic CTR on AI Overview queries fall from about 1.41% to 0.64% year over year. Brands cited in the Overview did better than brands left out.
- A 2026 randomized field experiment found outbound organic clicks fell 39.8% when an AI Overview appeared, and zero-click searches rose 34.5%.
- Ranking #1 on a classic SERP still matters. It matters less when Google answers the question on the results page first.
What “CTR” means on these two kinds of results pages
Click-through rate (CTR) is clicks divided by impressions. On a regular Google results page (SERP), people see a list of links. Many of them click one.
On a page with an AI Overview, Google puts a generated answer at the top. People can read that answer and leave. They can also click a citation inside the Overview, or scroll to the classic links. Most of the time, they do neither.
So you are not comparing the same attention. An AI Overview SERP competes with the answer Google already gave. A regular SERP mostly competes with other links.
AI Overviews vs regular SERPs: the key studies
No single study is perfect. Together they tell a clear story.
| Source | What they measured | AI Overview SERPs | Regular / comparison | Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ahrefs (Dec 2025 update) | Position 1 organic CTR from aggregated Search Console data across ~300k keywords | Actual pos-1 CTR ~1.6% on keywords that later trigger AI Overviews | ~3.7% predicted without AI Overviews (after adjusting for the wider CTR decline) | ~58% lower pos-1 CTR with AI Overviews |
| Pew Research (March 2025 browsing) | Next action after a Google visit (900 U.S. adults) | 8% clicked a traditional result; 1% clicked an AI citation | 15% clicked a traditional result when no AI summary showed | Almost half as likely to click a blue link when an AI summary is present |
| Seer Interactive | Organic CTR on informational queries with vs without AI Overviews | ~0.64% organic CTR (down from ~1.41% YoY on AIO queries) | Non-AIO queries held up better; in one analysis their organic CTR rose | AIO queries lose clicks; being cited in the Overview softens the hit |
| Agarwal & Sen field experiment (2026) | Randomized hide / show AI Overview via Chrome extension (~68k searches) | Outbound organic clicks −39.8%; zero-click +34.5% | Same searches with Overview hidden | Causal evidence that the Overview itself removes organic clicks |
rocketblue earlier covered Ahrefs’ first finding that AI Overviews cut clicks by 34.5%. The newer Ahrefs update says the gap has grown to about 58% for position one. That matches the direction of Pew, Seer, and the field experiment.
Why regular SERPs still win on clicks
On a classic results page, the top organic link often earns a large share of clicks. Exact CTR varies by query type, brand, and device. The point is simple: when there is no AI answer above the fold, people look at the links.
When an AI Overview appears:
- The Overview takes the best screen space.
- Many queries get a “good enough” answer without a click.
- Classic results get pushed down, so even a #1 ranking feels like #2 or worse.
- Citation clicks inside the Overview are rare (Pew’s ~1%).
Ahrefs also found the CTR hit is worst at the top of the page and smaller farther down. Position 1 lost about 58%. Positions 2–10 still lost clicks, but the absolute rates were already low.
Being inside the AI Overview changes the math
Lower average CTR does not mean every brand loses equally.
Seer’s work is useful here. When a brand showed up in the AI Overview, organic CTR was higher than when it did not (about 1.02% vs 0.74% in their reported split). Paid CTR also looked stronger when the brand was cited. That fits a simple idea: people trust results that match the answer Google just showed.
So the comparison is really three states, not two:
- Regular SERP, no AI Overview — classic link CTR is relatively healthy.
- AI Overview SERP, you are cited — fewer total clicks on the page, but you get a share of attention and a better chance of the remaining clicks.
- AI Overview SERP, you are not cited — you fight for leftover attention under an answer that may already name competitors.
That is why AI visibility tracking now sits next to classic rank tracking. If you only watch position, you miss whether Google’s answer names you at all. rocketblue’s own checks show Google often skips the Overview or names no brand on buyer prompts — see our analysis of when AI Overviews skip your prompt.
What this means for Search Console
Many teams see the same pattern in Google Search Console:
- Impressions hold or rise.
- Clicks flatten or fall.
- Average CTR drops, even when average position looks stable.
That is the “great decoupling” of impressions and clicks. Google still shows your URL. Users just need it less often when the Overview answers first.
Search Console still does not break out AI Overview performance as its own report. So you cannot see “AIO CTR” with one click. You have to combine GSC trends with a tracker that records when Overviews appear and whether you are mentioned.
What to do about the CTR gap
You cannot turn AI Overviews off for everyone. You can change how you measure and what you optimize for.
- Split your query set. Mark which important queries trigger AI Overviews and which stay as classic SERPs. Treat them as different channels.
- Track citation, not only rank. For Overview queries, ask: Does Google name us? Does it name competitors? Which URLs get cited?
- Protect non-Overview demand. Queries without Overviews still drive cleaner organic CTR. Keep winning those.
- Build pages worth citing. Clear answers, original data, and pages that already rank tend to show up as supporting links.
- Watch AI Mode and other engines too. Google’s AI Mode and tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity create another layer of zero-click answers. CTR on classic SERPs is only one piece of discovery.
If you want weekly checks across Google AI Overviews and the other major AI platforms, rocketblue tracks brand mentions, citations, and competitor share of voice on the prompts that matter to your buyers.
FAQ
What is the CTR difference between Google AI Overviews and regular SERPs?
Studies put the organic click loss on AI Overview pages in a wide but consistent range. Ahrefs estimates about a 58% lower position-one CTR when an Overview is present. Pew found traditional-result clicks at 8% of visits with an AI summary vs 15% without. A 2026 field experiment measured a 39.8% drop in outbound organic clicks when the Overview was shown.
Do people click the links inside Google AI Overviews?
Rarely. Pew Research found that only about 1% of visits to pages with an AI summary led to a click on a cited source in the summary. Most people either leave satisfied or keep searching without opening those links.
Is ranking #1 still useful when an AI Overview appears?
Yes, but it is worth less than it used to be. Ahrefs shows the biggest CTR drop at position one. You still want the ranking for the clicks that remain, for brand presence, and because the same pages often feed Overview citations. Ranking alone is no longer enough.
Does being cited in an AI Overview improve CTR?
Seer’s data suggests yes relative to not being cited. Brands that appeared in the Overview had higher organic and paid CTR than brands that did not on those queries. The page still gets fewer clicks overall than a classic SERP. Citation helps you win a bigger share of a smaller pie.
Why is my Search Console CTR falling while impressions rise?
AI Overviews and other zero-click features let Google answer without a visit to your site. Your URL can still earn impressions. Fewer people need to click. That gap between impressions and clicks is common on informational queries that trigger Overviews.
How should I measure success if organic CTR is down?
Keep watching organic CTR, but add AI-specific metrics: Overview presence rate, brand mention rate when an Overview shows, citation share vs competitors, and referral traffic from AI tools in analytics. Judge Overview queries and classic SERP queries apart so one number does not hide the other.
Where can I read the original CTR studies?
Start with Ahrefs’ AI Overviews CTR update, Pew’s AI summary click analysis, Seer’s AIO CTR study, and the Agarwal & Sen field experiment on SSRN.
Michael Hermon
Before rocketblue, Michael led Innovation and AI at monday.com after exiting his previous startup. He learned to code at 13 at MIT and later attended Columbia’s MBA program.
https://linkedin.com/in/michaelhermon